As of March 4, 2026, Xavier College Preparatory welcomed Carol Ann Michaelson ‘89 as its new principal, marking the school’s first principal since the retirement of Sister Joanie Nuckols in 2023.
Michaelson had been serving as interim principal for a year before officially being awarded the title. She has been dedicated to Xavier for over 30 years; first as a student, then as a theology teacher and later as director of student records.
The selection process for the role was lengthy but intentional. “The search likely involved careful consideration of candidates, gathering input from different stakeholders and ensuring alignment with Xavier’s mission and long-term vision. Taking the time to do that well ultimately benefits the entire community,” said Tara Metzger, assistant to the president.
The process itself extended beyond the Xavier campus, involving both local and national outreach. According to Sister Joan Fitzgerald, president of Xavier, the position “was posted for two months, locally and nationally,” followed by interviews with both school and diocesan representatives.
For Fitzgerald, Michaelson’s dedication to Xavier stood out immediately. “She certainly knows our mission,” Fitzgerald said, noting her experience as a student, teacher and administrator.
Her academic background also played a role in the decision. Fitzgerald explained that Michaelson’s degrees allow her to understand “what’s coming in high school” and “what’s going to be expected” of students beyond Xavier.
Michaelson holds a Bachelor of Arts (BA) in elementary education and a master’s degree in higher education.
Beyond credentials, her experience working directly with students was especially impactful. As director of student records, she developed an understanding of the needs and the tensions of the students, Fitzgerald said.
Michaelson herself describes her leadership style as “present, student-centered and mission-driven.” She emphasized the importance of being connected to student life on campus.
“I hope students experience a principal who is visible around campus, showing up at their events, knowing their names, and listening when they have concerns,” Michaelson said.
In her first year, Michaelson is prioritizing listening over immediate changes. “My focus is less on change and more on listening and discernment,” she said.
She hopes to build on Xavier’s strengths while preparing for the future. “I want to preserve Xavier’s strong sense of sisterhood and the deep-rooted Catholic identity, while continuing to evolve especially as we prepare students for a rapidly changing world,” Michaelson explained.
Those who work closely with her have already seen this approach in action. Metzger described her leadership as “quiet confidence that is both steady and intentional,” emphasizing her ability to listen and make thoughtful decisions.
Much of Michaelson’s work happens behind the scenes, but it directly shapes the student experience. She is “constantly supporting faculty and staff, checking in on student needs, and working through complex situations with care and fairness,” Metzger said.
Looking ahead, the Xavier community anticipates continued growth under her leadership. Fitzgerald expressed confidence in the decision, stating, “I just think it’s going to get stronger” as Michaelson immerses herself into her role.
